Elbows Out

An independent Canadian accountability journal · 2025–2026

The promises.
The record.
The point.

Mark Carney took office on March 14, 2025 with a resume built for trust and a platform built on “tough choices.” We keep the receipts — every major promise, what actually happened, and 34 filed arguments on the gap between the two.

Read the promise tracker The balanced record

Latest arguments

All 34 arguments →

No. 03Trade & Foreign Affairs

A Border Divided: The Pragmatist Who Walked into a Trade War

Mark Carney campaigned as a steady hand who would bring pragmatic diplomacy to Canada’s most vital economic relationship: the United States. He promised to stabilize cross-border trade and protect Canadian industry…

Read the argument →

No. 33Economy & Affordability

The 15-Month Squeeze: When Food Prices Outpace the Economy

Throughout Mark Carney’s tenure, a glaring economic disparity has emerged: the cost of keeping a family fed has completely decoupled from broader economic metrics. For 15 consecutive months in 2025 and 2026, food…

Read the argument →

A leader who was supposed to be the adult in the room on economic policy has instead proven willing to borrow heavily to avoid political pain.

File No. 01 — The Fiscal Illusion